Council Approves Three-Year Chamber Events Deal, Raises Parade Cap to $60,000

Taxpayer subsidies in focus as council debates the future of its agreement with Chamber of Commerce. Three-year deal approved, but with 30 day cancellation rights.

Council Approves Three-Year Chamber Events Deal, Raises Parade Cap to $60,000
The annual St. Patricks Day Parade is currently produced by the Chamber Foundation with substantial support from city funds.

The Hermosa Beach City Council on Monday approved a three-year agreement with the Hermosa Beach Chamber of Commerce and its Foundation to produce the city's signature special events through 2029. The deal raises the city's ceiling for St. Patrick's Day Parade costs to $60,000 and continues fee waivers the city valued at $319,332 this year.

The 5-0 vote at a special meeting followed a 1-4 defeat of Councilmember Raymond Jackson's substitute motion to limit the agreement to 2027 alone. Three councilmembers raised concerns about subsidies and the city's budget during deliberation. Two of them, Mayor Mike Detoy and Councilmember Dean Francois, then voted against the one-year option and for the three-year term.

The agreement covers Sidewalk Sales, the St. Patrick's Day Parade, Memorial Day and Labor Day Fiesta Hermosa, and Hermosa for the Holidays from Jan. 1, 2027, through Dec. 31, 2029. It replaces a one-year 2026 agreement the council approved in January after declining a three-year term at that time.

What the city is paying

The city will reimburse the Chamber Foundation up to $60,000 for private security, additional barricades, insurance and Los Angeles County Fire Department services for the 2027 Parade. The council authorized up to $51,125 for the 2026 Parade.

The city actually paid $26,699 for the 2026 Parade, according to the Chamber's post-event accounting. The Foundation later returned $9,896, leaving the city's net cash cost at about $16,800. The new cap is about 2.25 times what the city paid this year.

City Manager Steve Napolitano, who presented the item because Parks and Recreation Director Lisa Nichols was ill, attributed the higher cap "mainly" to "additional costs that the county has imposed regarding emergency services during the parade."

The Foundation's Oct. 14 letter requesting the funding itemizes the costs it wants the city to cover: $9,000 for private security and public safety staffing, $1,600 for insurance, $900 for the Fire Department, $550 for two EMT teams, $2,100 for two bike medics and $1,700 for two ambulances. Those items total $15,850. Street barriers and city permit fees are listed as "TBD."

The $60,000 applies to the 2027 Parade only. Funding for 2028 and 2029 will require a separate council vote after a post-event review.

The agreement continues to waive indirect city costs for all five event programs and all direct city costs for the Parade. For the 2026 events, staff calculated $265,911 in waived indirect costs and $53,421 in waived direct costs. The largest indirect waivers were $86,484 for Memorial Day Fiesta, $69,660 for Labor Day Fiesta and $54,456 in Pier Plaza use fees for Sidewalk Sales, which brought in $4,303 in vendor revenue.

Shuttle cap rises to $65,000

The new agreement also raises the city's annual cap on Proposition A transit funds for the free Fiesta shuttle from $35,000 to $65,000. Over three years, that allows up to $90,000 more in reimbursements than the old cap.

The increase does not appear in the staff report's summary of "primary proposed changes." It appeared as a single line on a supplemental slide presented Monday. Napolitano said Prop A shuttle funds were "included" in the city's support but did not mention the higher cap, and no councilmember raised it.

The Chamber reported 2026 shuttle costs of $30,750 for Memorial Day Fiesta and $26,400 for Labor Day Fiesta.

Surplus return not required

Francois asked whether the city would again receive any Parade surplus. Napolitano said returning the $9,896 "wasn't required last year. The chamber was gracious enough to do it."

Napolitano said the new agreement does not require it either, adding, "We could add that, though, with your approval tonight." The motion the council approved did not add it.

Chamber CEO Michelle Crispin told the council the Foundation had met with the Kiwanis Club about a possible Parade partnership and hoped, together with a 5K, to "give back to you again this year."

"We hope that we won't hit that $60,000 mark," she said. She added that the Kiwanis had "expressed interest in maybe even taking over the event."

What the Chamber earned

The Chamber and Foundation reported about $1.23 million in revenue and $1.05 million in expenses across the 2026 events. Memorial Day Fiesta produced $186,364 in net income. Labor Day Fiesta, which Napolitano said was hurt by weather, netted $3,962.

Staff reported total net income of $204,992. That figure counts the Parade at its $9,896 adjusted net after city support, while the table's revenue and expense columns leave the city's $26,699 out. Total revenue minus total expenses as printed comes to $178,293.

Crispin said Fiesta revenue funds the Chamber's operations. "It is our fundraiser, period," she said. She said the Chamber expects to finish 2026 "in the black" after cutting costs.

Thirty-day exit

The new agreement allows either the city or the Chamber to terminate on 30 days' written notice if it decides, "in its sole discretion," that continuing is "no longer feasible or in its interest." The current agreement's termination clause requires 90 days' notice.

Mayor Pro Tem Michael Keegan, who chaired the meeting while Detoy attended by video from Sacramento on CalPERS board business, cited the clause in support of the three-year term.

"So it essentially is a one-month agreement, you know, month-to-month, in a sense," Keegan said.

Councilmember Rob Saemann made the same argument when he moved approval. "I think the three-year contract is actually a one-year contract because it can be negated at any time," he said.

Deliberations

Jackson said he could not support a three-year commitment. "I think because of our financial uncertainties right now, I think locking ourselves in for three years is a bridge too far," he said. He pointed to a "budget reckoning" early next year and said "a line-by-line review is going to be critical."

Detoy said locking in "a three-year deal with the financial outlay in this commitment is a lot to stomach right now." Francois said, "There's a lot of subsidies here going on," and asked "what's the harm in looking at this again at the end of next year."

Saemann said the subsidies were modest year to year. "I don't think we're gonna solve the budget, the $3.5 million problem on the back of the chamber," he said.

Keegan said he had attended more than 40 Fiestas and heard the same debate under "probably six different chamber directors." He said Hermosa's small business community "really can't support a chamber in a lot of ways" and that the city has been "giving up parking for a couple decades."

Jackson's substitute motion for a 2027-only agreement failed, with Jackson voting yes and Detoy, Keegan, Saemann and Francois voting no.

Before the final vote, a proposal was made to allow the parties to modify the agreement's terms by mutual agreement on 30 days' notice. Interim City Attorney Jason Baltimore said the language could go in the agreement's amendment section, subject to the Chamber agreeing. 

Section 28 of the agreement already allows amendments in writing signed by all parties and approved by the council.

The amended motion passed 5-0. 

The new agreement adds higher insurance requirements, certified alcohol-service staffing and vendor seller-permit checks. It keeps the 60-day post-event financial reports and the December council presentation, but limits both to "Event-related information" and states they "need not include entity-wide financial information."

Francois said he would favor moving the annual review from December to November. Keegan said the council had asked the city manager to bring it back "in August or September."

Public comment

Resident Matt McCool urged a one-year term, citing the Chamber's failure to provide its 2025 IRS Form 990 filings and more than $320,000 a year in fee waivers. He said the city should split Fiesta revenue 50-50 "until the city recoups its cost" and look for other event partners.

The Chamber representative later said the Chamber had received its final 2025 Form 990s that day and would share them.

Tony Higgins said residents pay full cost recovery for permits while the Chamber's events receive "hundreds of thousands of dollars in taxpayer subsidies."

The 2026 Hermosa for the Holidays event, the last held under the current agreement, is scheduled for this weekend.


Great! You’ve successfully signed up.

Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.

You've successfully subscribed to The Hermosa Review.

Success! Check your email for magic link to sign-in.

Success! Your billing info has been updated.

Your billing was not updated.